Before we get into what arousal non-concordance means, let’s start with arousal itself. What does that word really mean? We often use arousal and desire interchangeably, but they describe two different parts of intimacy. And trust me, knowing the difference can make some of your own experiences a lot less confusing.
Desire is the wanting. It’s the interest, curiosity or wish to be intimate with yourself or someone else. You might feel it out of the blue, or it might grow once you’re already sharing a moment that feels good.
Arousal is the response. This is how your genitals or parts of your body respond. You might notice more lubrication, swelling or an erection.
Sometimes the wanting comes first. Sometimes you start to feel turned on, and the wanting follows. And sometimes, even when you feel very turned on, your genitals respond differently from how you’d expect. That’s where arousal non-concordance comes in.
What is arousal non-concordance?
Have you ever noticed your body responding to touch when you didn’t feel turned on? Or felt really turned on and wondered why you were still dry or why you hadn’t got an erection? Arousal non-concordance is when your genital response and how turned on you feel don’t line up. Emily Nagoski helped popularise the term in her 2015 book Come As You Are.
Why does arousal non-concordance happen?
Nagoski makes a distinction between what’s sexually relevant and what’s sexually appealing. A sensation, an image or something you read can register as a cue that triggers a physical response. For example, a medical examination around the genitals may trigger a response, such as an erection, while all you’re thinking about is when the exam will be over. Something sexually relevant is happening, but it’s not sexually appealing for most. Your nervous system can respond to the sensation automatically, even when you feel neutral, uncomfortable or uninterested.
It can happen the other way round, too. You can be enjoying yourself, feel excited about what’s happening and still notice very little change in your body. And wetness and erections can vary for reasons that have little to do with how turned on you feel. For example, breastfeeding, menopause, stress and some medicines can all affect our physical responses during sex. Here are some other common causes of why this might be happening:
Stress and tiredness
You might be enjoying being close to someone, then realise you’re already running through tomorrow’s to-do list. When your attention drifts, it can be harder to feel turned on, even if your body is still responding to touch.
Hormones, medication and health
You can feel just as turned on as usual and notice less lubrication around menopause or while breastfeeding, or notice that an erection is harder to maintain during times of stress or pressure. Also, some medicines, including certain antidepressants and blood pressure medications, can affect lubrication or erections. Finally, alcohol or even smoking can make it harder to get or keep an erection, as can conditions such as diabetes that affect blood vessels or nerves. Pain can change the experience too. You might feel turned on and still find that a particular kind of touch hurts.
Past trauma can affect how you experience intimacy
A particular kind of touch or position might bring up a memory that changes how you feel, even with someone you trust and during intimacy you wanted. In that moment, you might feel less turned on or less present while still noticing a physical response. Genital responses can also happen involuntarily during unwanted contact. Consent comes from what you freely agree to.
What does this mean in the moment?
If you find yourself wondering, Why am I still dry? I’m really enjoying this; you can say exactly that. “I’m enjoying this. Can we use some lube?” And if you’re trying to work out how a partner feels, ask them. “How does this feel?” or “Would you like me to keep going?” gives them room to tell you what they actually want.
How to work with arousal non-concordance
If you notice yourself thinking, “Why isn’t my body doing what I expected?” try asking, “What would make this feel better for me right now?”
If you feel turned on but dry, or an erection is not happening, that might mean reaching for some lube or asking to slow down or something different, or even stopping altogether.
If you’re enjoying the closeness but feel pressure to get or keep an erection, you can say, “I’m enjoying this. Can we take the pressure off and stay here for a bit?” And if your body is responding but you’d rather stop, you can stop.
If dryness, pain or erection changes keep happening and bother you, a GP can help you explore possible causes. If it’s bringing up anxiety, shame or difficult memories, a psychosexual therapist can help you talk it through at your own pace.
Sources & further reading.
- Nagoski, E.. unwanted arousal: it happens
- Meredith L Chivers, Michael C Seto, Martin L Lalumière, Ellen Laan, Teresa Grimbos. Agreement of Self-Reported and Genital Measures of Sexual Arousal in Men and Women: A Meta-Analysis